How to do without palm oil?3160x 04. 02. 2020 1 Reader
It's a miraculous product used everywhere, from confectionery to construction. For our dependence on palm oil, however, planet Earth pays for the damage caused by rainforests. Can we replace it with something?
He was probably in the shampoo you used this morning, the soap you washed, the toothpaste you brushed your teeth, the vitamin tablets you swallowed, or the makeup you put on your face. It could also be in the bread that you had toast for breakfast, in the margarine that you put on it, or in the cream that you put in the coffee. If you used butter and milk, the cow they came from was probably also fed with palm oil. It's almost certain that you used palm oil today.
Even the vehicle you were driving today - bus, train or car - ran on fuel containing palm oil. Much of the diesel and gasoline that we use has an added component of biofuel, which comes mainly from palm oil. Even the electricity that powers the device on which you are reading this article now can be partly produced by burning oil palm kernels.
Palm oil is the most popular vegetable oil in the world. It is contained in 50% of consumer products and also plays a central role in many industrial applications. Farmers produced 2018 million tonnes of palm oil on the world market in 77, and production is expected to increase to 2024 million tonnes by 107,6.
The ubiquity of palm oil is partly due to its unique chemical composition. It is obtained from the seeds of West African oil palm, it is bright in color and odorless, which makes it a suitable food ingredient. The oil has a high melting point and a high content of saturated fats, which is ideal for the production of confectionery products and creams that pleasantly dissolve in the mouth. Most other vegetable oils must be partially hydrogenated (hydrogen atoms are chemically added to fat molecules) to achieve similar consistency, a process that leads to unhealthy trans fats.
The unique chemical composition of palm oil also allows it to withstand high cooking temperatures and provides high perishability, giving it a long shelf life for the products in which it is found. Oil can also be used as a fuel, as well as palm kernels left over after processing. The husks can be crushed and used to produce concrete, and the ash that remains after the burning of palm fibers and cores can be used as a cement substitute.
Oil palms are also easy to grow in the tropics and are highly profitable for farmers, even in hard-to-grow areas that have quickly shifted to growing this crop in recent years.
Indonesia and Malaysia alone boast about 13 million hectares of oil palm plantations, almost half of the world's production.
However, the rapid expansion of oil palm plantations is accused of massive deforestation in Indonesia and Malaysia and of destroying the habitat of wild endangered animals such as orangutan and increasing the risk of extinction. These two countries boast about 13 million hectares of oil palm plantations, which is almost half of the world's production. According to Global Forest Watch, Indonesia lost 2001 million hectares of forest between 2018 and 25,6, an area almost as large as New Zealand.
This has prompted governments and businesses to seek alternatives to palm oil. However, replacing a miracle product is not easy. The Iceland chain was awarded in 2018 when it announced that it would gradually remove palm oil from all its own brand products (it also came with a moving Christmas ad with a homeless orangutan, but it was banned for obvious political focus). Yet the removal of palm oil from some products proved so difficult that the company preferred to remove its brand the following year.
Food giant General Mills - one of the largest buyers of palm oil in the US - has encountered similar problems. "Even though we have been deeply involved in this issue, palm oil provides such unique physical properties that it is very difficult to imitate," says spokesperson Mollie Wulff.
The most common approach is to search for other vegetable oils that offer similar properties. In designing palm oil-free soap, the British cosmetic brand LUSH resorted to a mixture of rapeseed and coconut oil. Since then, it has moved further and developed Movis, a custom-made soap base containing sunflower oil, cocoa butter, extra virgin coconut oil and wheat germ.
Meanwhile, food and cosmetics scientists are attempting to produce blends with even more exotic alternatives, such as shea butter, damara, jojoba, mangosteen, ilipé, ragweed or mango kernels. By partially hydrogenating and mixing these "exotic oils", a mixture with similar properties to palm oil can be formed. But none of these ingredients is as cheap or readily available as palm oil. For example, African shea nuts are collected and sold by local communities in small volumes instead of planting, resulting in a limited and unstable supply.
These are not the only recipes whose improvement could lead to the avoidance of palm oil. As with soybeans - other crops accused of destroying rainforests - most palm oil is intended for animal feed, both farm and pet. In addition to being highly caloric, palm oil is rich in essential fatty acids and aids in the absorption of fat-soluble vitamins. With the increasing worldwide demand for meat, poultry and dairy products, the demand for palm oil is also rising.
Scientists from the University of Poznan in Poland have examined whether palm oil in chicken feed can be replaced by a more sustainable source of nutrition: insects. The team fed chickens instead of palm oil with a diet supplemented with the beetle larva oil and found that it grew equally well, and even showed improved meat quality. These worms are also high in protein and can be used for food waste. The British Veterinary Association has recently concluded that insect-based feed would be better for breeding animals than top quality steak as well as for the environment.
Despite its ubiquity in pantry and bathrooms, more than half of the palm oil imported into the European Union in 2017 was used for something else - fuel. The EU Renewable Energy Directive has set an ambitious target for 2020% of energy for road transport to come from renewable sources by 10. And biodiesel, made from palm oil, was a major contributor to achieving this goal. However, in 2019 the EU announced that biofuels derived from palm oil and other food crops must be phased out due to the environmental damage associated with their production.
Algae produce oil, very similar to palm oil, to cover their spores and better survive in dry conditions
This decision prompted the EU to seek an alternative. One possibility is algae. Oil from certain types of algae can be converted to bioropa, which can then be distilled into a range of fuels that could replace diesel, jet fuel and even heavy marine oil. This may not be as strange as it seems: most oil fields around the world are fossilized remains of algae.
David Nelson is a plant geneticist who investigates the potential of algae. His genetic research on Chloroidium, a microscopic algae common in Abu Dhabi, suggests that it could be a real alternative to palm oil.
"We have an interesting climate, not too rainy, it is hot in the summer, so everything that grows must be able to cope with it," says Nelson, headquartered at the University of Abu Dhabi, New York. "One way this kelp does is to produce oil."
The kelp produces oil very similar to palm oil, which it coats its disputes to help survive in arid conditions. His team hopes to grow algae in vats or open ponds, which would allow this oil to be collected. But Nelson says that big market changes will be needed to do this.
"If politicians say" No, we will not use palm oil, "then there is a really large and open market for algae" palm "oil," he says.
Nelson is not the only one hoping for an algae boom. ExxonMobil and Synthetic Genomics announced in 2017 that they have created an algae strain that produces twice as much oil as its predecessor. Last year, Honda set up an experimental algae farm at its Ohio plant to capture carbon dioxide from test engine centers. They hope that the system will become modular in order to extend it to more plants. And the biotechnology company Solazyme, based in San Francisco, has even developed algae fuels for automotive, aircraft and military use.
However, the main obstacle is to get these products to a stage where they will be able to compete economically and in quantity with palm oil. In 2013, the University of Ohio created a pilot algae farm, but its chief, mechanical engineer David Bayless, admitted that they had made little progress over the past six years. "The brief answer is no, we are not closer." The problem remains the economy and the commercial production of algal oil for the commodity market is still very far, "he says. "I wish I had better news for you."
Under ideal conditions, highly productive palm cultivars can produce more than 25 times as much oil as is derived from soybean cultivation on an equally large area of farmland.
Some companies are also investigating whether yeast could be bred to produce the types of oils required by the food and cosmetics industry. However, work on this task is at an earlier stage than algae oil farms. However, in addition to the economic side, there is another problem in replacing palm oil with microorganisms such as algae or yeast. The most controlled and efficient way to grow them is the large closed vats, but in this system sugar needs to be added in large quantities to support their growth. This sugar must be grown somewhere, so the environmental impact of the final product is simply shifted away. According to Bonsucro non-profit certifiers, only 4% of the world's sugar is grown in sustainable conditions.
If we are unable to replace palm oil, perhaps we could reduce its environmental impact by changing the way it is produced. To achieve this, we need to take a step back and see what determines his demand.
In addition to its unique composition, palm oil is also very cheap. That's because an oil palm is something of a miracle - it grows relatively fast, is easy to harvest, and is amazingly productive. A hectare of oil palm can reliably produce four tonnes of vegetable oil each year, compared to 0,67 tonnes for rapeseed, 0,48 tonnes for sunflowers and only 0,38 tonnes for soybeans. Under ideal conditions, high-yielding palm cultivars can produce more than 25 times as much oil as soya produces on the same area of farmland. Ironically, banning palm oil would lead to a catastrophic increase in deforestation, because anything that we replace will require much more land to grow.
However, it is possible to grow oil palm in a way that limits the environmental impact. Most Western companies buy palm oil that is certified by Rountable for Sustainable Palm Oil (RPSO) However, the demand for this certified sustainable palm oil and the willingness to pay a higher price for it is limited. The market for sustainable palm oil is oversold, leading to producers selling certified oil to a wider market without the appropriate labeling. RPSO has been criticized as opaque and ineffective, with the negligible influence of forcing growers to change.
"The Malaysian Palm Oil Council talks about sustainable palm oil, but somehow I don't find that they sell anything sustainable," says Kyle Reynolds, a scientist who recently worked at the Australian CSIRO research center.
The oil palm grows only up to 20 degrees from the equator - an area where rainforests are growing and which is home to 80% of all species in the world. What if we could reduce the pressure on tropical rainforests by breeding a plant that was as productive as an oil palm but could grow anywhere? That's what Reynolds and his colleagues are working on.
"The oil palm cannot grow too far south or north, it is largely a tropical crop," Reynolds says. "Something with such a high biomass content should be more adaptable and capable of growing in different climatic conditions."
In a laboratory in Canberra, CSIRO scientists have introduced genes for high levels of oil production into deciduous plants such as tobacco and sorghum. Plants can be crushed and oil can be extracted from their leaves. Tobacco leaves typically contain less than 1% vegetable oil, but Reynolds' plants boast up to 35%, which means they provide even more vegetable oil than soybeans.
Scientists have introduced genes for high levels of oil production into deciduous plants such as tobacco and sorghum
There is still a possibility: an attempt at this leaf oil in the US has failed, probably because of the local climate (in Australia, a transgenic plant cannot be legally grown). And the tobacco plant oil is still "far away" from palm oil because its fatty acids are longer and unsaturated. This means that processing would be required to achieve similar properties. But Reynolds argues that it may take about 12 months to breed new and improved tobacco to produce oil - if someone is willing to invest in the necessary research.
"It is a huge industry, with the current value of oil palm being $ 67 billion," says Reynolds. He repeats Nelson's fears. 'It should be possible to extract palm oil from a plant other than an oil palm. We can do it? Sure. But will the price be competitive? "
Obviously, palm oil is not going anywhere. It is almost impossible to avoid it, and it is just as difficult to confuse it for something. However, scientific potential can mitigate our impact on the world by developing more sustainable ways to meet our food, fuel and cosmetic needs. All that is needed is the will for this change to take place - and for that will to become ubiquitous as palm oil itself.